Back to Authors

Shanafelt, Tait D.

https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7106-5202

Mayo Clinic

Stanford Cancer Institute

Citations 372

Molecular and Clinical Analysis of a Midwest Cohort of B-CLL Patients Utilizing the Immunoglobulin VH 1-69 Gene.
Tschumper, Renee C. , Geyer, Susan, Mulvihill, Erin M., Jelinek, Diane F., Shanafelt, Tait D. , Kay, Neil E.

Blood | April 19, 2020 | Volume: 106 | Issue: 11 | Pages: 5016-5016

10.1182/blood.v106.11.5016.5016 Get It

Abstract The prognostic power of immunoglobulin (Ig) somatic mutation status in B cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia (B-CLL) is widely appreciated and has served as the rationale to systematically determine this molecular feature in B-CLL patients. Consistent with other reports, our study of Ig mutation status in a large cohort of B-CLL patients (n=599) found the most commonly used Ig heavy chain variable (VH) region gene was VH 1–69. The VH1–69 gene is of particular interest as there are numerous reports demonstrating that VH1–69 expressing B-CLL cells predominantly express the 51p1-like allele in an unmutated (UM) form and it is frequently associated with use of the D gene segment, D3-3; the J gene segment, JH6; and a relatively long third, complementarity-determining region (CDR3). Despite molecular definition of a commonly used form of VH1–69 in B-CLL, the clinical significance of CLL B cell usage of this prototypic form of VH1–69 remains to be determined. The goal of this study, therefore, was to perform a molecular and clinical analysis on our cohort of B-CLL patients expressing the VH1–69 gene. Our cohort consisted of 19 females and 55 males, with 89.5% expressing UM Ig VH. The 51p1-like allele was present in 75.7% of patients and the predominant D region used was D3 (64.7%). Patients in our cohort were classified by Rai risk as follows: 20 low (28.2%), 40 intermediate (56.3%), and 11 high (15.5%). For those patients with Rai stage available, analysis of specific D and J regions resulted in 16 D3-3/JH6 (26.7%); 14 D3-3/non-JH6 (23.3%); 16 non-D3-3/JH6 (26.7%); and 14 non-D3-3/non-JH6 (23.3%). Despite observing an overwhelming majority of leukemic cells with UM Ig VH, and the known relationship between mutation status and disease progression, it is interesting that our cohort included almost 30% with a low Rai risk. Of note, Ig VH mutation status did not segregate with Rai risk group or VH1–69 allele use (although few patients overall were mutated). However, an UM Ig VH status was associated with a CDR3 length >20 (p = 0.001) and with use of the JH6 segment (p = 0.003). When mutation status was analyzed in concert with specific use of the D3-3 allele, no relationship emerged; however, when this D region allele was analyzed for JH6 vs non-JH6 usage, combination of the D3-3 allele with JH6 was significantly associated with an UM Ig VH status (p = 0.004). Moreover, when J and D segment usage was analyzed in concert with Rai stage group, a significant (p = 0.019) relationship emerged between paired use of D3-3 and a JH6 segment and advanced (intermediate/high) Rai stage. Strikingly, only 1 of 18 VH1–69 patients with low Rai risk for whom D and J data were available expressed the specific combination of D3-3 and JH6. Although analysis of a larger cohort is clearly required to more formally and fully evaluate these relationships, to our knowledge, this is the first suggestion that D and J usage in VH1-69 expressing B-CLL patients correlates with advanced stages of disease. Because Ig VH usage is not believed to change over the course of disease, it is tempting to speculate that VH1–69 B-CLL patients that do not express the prototypic VH1–69 receptor may have a more favorable disease course. In summary, these data add further support to the notion that there is selection for specific Ig receptors in B-CLL and that the antigenic specificity of certain receptors may be associated with risk of progression.
Submicroscopic Interstitial Deletions in 13q14 Are Detectable in Metaphase Cells by Fluorescence In Situ Hybridization (FISH) with D13S319 in Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia (B-CLL).
Dyke, Daniel L. Van , Stockero, Kimberly J., Fink, Stephanie, Smoley, Stephanie A., Paternoster, Sarah F., Schwager, Susan M., Call, Timothy G. , Dewald, Gordon W., Shanafelt, Tait D. , Zent, Clive S. , Kay, Neil E.

Blood | April 19, 2020 | Volume: 106 | Issue: 11 | Pages: 3278-3278

10.1182/blood.v106.11.3278.3278 Get It

Abstract Background: Results of conventional cytogenetic studies on specimens processed without B-cell mitogens are usually normal in B-CLL: this observation is often attributed to lack of mitotic B-CLL cells. Using metaphase FISH with D13S319, we now have evidence that these apparently normal mitotic B-CLL cells often exhibit submicroscopic interstitial deletions in 13q14. This observation indicates B-CLL cells do divide in unstimulated cultures, but the abnormal metaphases are not detected because the abnormalities are submicroscopic and represent a low percentage of proliferating cells. Methods: We studied 12 patients with B-CLL who had normal metaphases by conventional cytogenetics, but abnormal interphase nuclei by FISH with D13S319. This cohort consisted of 7 females and 5 males who ranged in age from 50 to 87 years. Clinical information was available for 11 patients: Rai stages were 0, I, II, III, or IV for 6, 1, 1, 2, and 1 patients, respectively; 8 patients received treatment and 3 have died. Conventional cytogenetic studies and metaphase FISH were done on bone marrow specimens that were processed by standard 24 and 48-hour unstimulated cultures with Chang Medium BMC. Interphase FISH studies were done on blood or bone marrow (collected within 3 days of specimens for conventional cytogenetic studies) using probes to detect anomalies of chromosomes 6, 11, 12, 13, 14 and 17. For each patient, metaphase FISH was done with commercial probes from Vysis Inc., Downers Grove, IL for D13S319/13q34 using leftover fixed cells from conventional cytogenetics studies. Results: Metaphase FISH results were normal for 3 bone marrow specimens: the remaining 9 specimens had 1.9 to 13.8% metaphases with interstitial deletions of 13q14. One patient had a cytogenetically visible chromosome 13 deletion in 2.2% of metaphases. In the remaining 8 specimens, the size of the abnormal 13 was similar to the normal 13 homolog and other acrocentric chromosomes. By comparison, interphase FISH revealed 13 to 93% nuclei with 13q-x1 or 13q-x2. Seven patients had additonal anomalies in their interphase nuclei; 3 had 11q-, 2 had 17p-, 1 had +12 and 1 had +IGH. Conclusions: This investigation indicates that metaphase FISH detects submicroscopic deletions in chromosome 13 as well as infrequent mitotic B-CLL cells in patients who have normal conventional cytogenetic results. Therefore, metaphase FISH is a novel and useful technique to detect abnormal mitotic cells in B-CLL in cultures without special B-cell mitogens. The prognostic significance of abnormal metaphase FISH results is still under investigation. We speculate that this method will allow for identification of more aggressive proliferating disease even in so-called “favorable” prognostic groups based on interphase FISH results.
Proteomic Analysis of Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia Cells Identifies Vimentin as a Novel Prognostic Factor for Aggressive Disease.
Nowakowski, Grzegorz S. , Bone, Nancy D., Morice, William G. , Barnidge, David R. , Jelinek, Diane F., Tschumper, Renee C. , Rassenti, Laura Z., Lee, Yean Kee , Morice, William George , Shanafelt, Tait D. , Zent, Clive S. , Kipps, Thomas J. , Kay, Neil E.

Blood | April 19, 2020 | Volume: 106 | Issue: 11 | Pages: 707-707

10.1182/blood.v106.11.707.707 Get It

Abstract The IgVH mutation status is an independent predictor of time to treatment and survival in CLL. However, the biological basis of this difference is unknown. Clinical use of the IgVH mutation status as a prognostic marker is limited due to the technical difficulties of assessing this feature. As such, we probed for differences in protein expression by CLL cells with unmutated (UM) vs mutated (M) IgVH using phage peptide display libraries (PDPL). Methods: PDPL consists of phages engineered to express random peptides (7-mer) on the coat protein. From approximately 2x1011 phages displaying all possible permutations of 7-mer peptide, we selected phages binding to UM cells by incubation with 106 UM cells and elution of bound phages. Then, from numerous phages initially binding to UM cells, we subtracted phages binding to M cells by multiple incubations with M cells (106). Thus, the phages that bound only to UM cells were selected. The procedure was repeated multiple times to increase selection specificity. The peptide sequences displayed by selected phages were evaluated. We identified phage targets on UM cells by immunoprecipitation (IP) of CLL protein with specific phage and by sequencing of precipitated protein. The expression of target protein in CLL cells was confirmed by immunobloting and flow cytometry. Results: Sequencing of phages from the 3rd round of selection (UM v. M) revealed several peptides, with the most predominant being FPSAHFL. IP identified the cellular target for FPSAHFL as vimentin, an intermediate filament protein involved in cell motility and activation. The level of vimentin expressed by CLL cells varied between patient samples (n=15). UM CLL cases were found to express higher levels of vimentin (the mean MFI was 1002; SD 381), than cases of M CLL (mean MFI 547; SD 109), p=0.0128. To evaluate the prognostic significance of vimentin, we assessed vimentin expression by flow cytometry in a separate subgroup of 40 CLL patients. Archived cell samples collected between 6/2000 – 6/2001 were used. The median follow up was 81 months (40–233). Vimentin expression (MFI) as a continuous variable was a risk factor for a shortened time to treatment (TTT) with a proportional hazard ratio of 4.152 (95% CI 1.33–15.220, p=0.0317). Using MFI closest to the median (and rounded to 2 decimal places) as a cutoff, we stratified patients in high (n=21) and low (n=19) vimentin expression groups. The median times to treatment (TTT) in patients with high vs low level expression of vimentin were 2.8 and 12.9 years respectively, p=0.0025 (Fig.). Conclusion: Using novel proteomic technology, we found that CLL cells with unmutated IgVH expressed higher levels of vimentin than CLL cells with mutated IgVH. A high-level of vimentin expression defined by flow cytometry appears to be associated with high-risk disease. Validation of these findings could allow for the vimentin level to be used as a surrogate marker for expression of unmutated IgVH in CLL. Figure Figure
Loss of p53 Is Due to Rearrangements in a ~6,400 kb Region of Low Copy Repeats near the Centromere of Chromosome 17 in Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia (B-CLL).
Dewald, Gordon W., Fink, Stephanie, Smoley, Stephanie A., Stockero, Kimberly J., Paternoster, Sarah F., Susan, S. Margulies, Thorland, Erik C., Dyke, Daniel L. Van , Call, Timothy G. , Shanafelt, Tait D. , Zent, Clive S. , Kay, Neil E.

Blood | April 19, 2020 | Volume: 106 | Issue: 11 | Pages: 3255-3255

10.1182/blood.v106.11.3255.3255 Get It

Abstract Background: Loss of p53 is detected by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) in interphase nuclei in 8–10% of patients with B-CLL and has been associated with aggressive disease and poor response to therapy. Results of chromosome studies suggest loss of p53 is often due to structural anomalies of chromosome 17 rather than monosomy 17. To characterize chromosome 17 anomalies in B-CLL, we used interphase and metaphase FISH to study a series of patients with this disorder. Methods: We studied 16 patients with B-CLL who had chromosome 17 anomalies detected by conventional chromosome studies or interphase FISH. The study cohort consisted of 8 females and 8 males (age 54 – 73 years). Clinical data was available for 15 patients: Rai stages were I, II, III and IV for 1, 2, 6 and 6 patients, respectively; 14 patients received treatment and 10 have died. Metaphase and interphase FISH studies were performed using left-over fixed bone marrow or peripheral blood cell pellets from conventional cytogenetic studies. To identify recurrent chromosome 17 breakpoint cluster regions, patients were first studied with p53(17p13.1) and D17Z1(centromere17), and then with FISH probes for SMS(17p11.2) and RARA(17q21). For patients retaining the SMS probe site, we did FISH for HNPP(17p11.2–12) and D17Z1(centromere17). A total of 200 interphase nuclei and up to 20 metaphases were analyzed by each probe set. Results: The karyotype was normal for 3 patients and complex involving various abnormalities of chromosome 17 for the remaining 13. All patients showed loss of one p53 probe site with retention of both chromosome 17 centromeres. The SMS locus was absent in 13 patients indicating a breakpoint cluster region between the centromere and SMS probe site. In the remaining 3 patients, HNPP was absent, but the SMS probe site was retained indicating chromosome breakage between the SMS and HNPP probe sites. Metaphase FISH results indicate loss of p53 was due to an isochromosome 17p11.2 in 4 patients and an unbalanced translocation involving 17p11.2 in 12 patients. Conclusions: This study shows that loss of p53 in B-CLL cells is due to isochromosome formation or unbalanced translocations that involve a ~6,400 kb breakpoint cluster region adjacent to the centromere on the short arm of chromosome 17. Importantly, our findings indicate that loss of p53 is not due to loss of chromosome 17, simple deletions of p53, or chromosome breakage near the p53 locus. The region between the centromere and HNPP on chromosome 17 is known to be rich in low copy repeats and homologous DNA sequences are dispersed throughout the genome. In somatic cells, these repeats can result in pairing of the same or different chromosomes; crossing over within these homologous regions can result in translocations or isochromosomes. Undoubtedly, this genetic mechanism plays an important role in the origin of structural anomalies of chromosome 17 in B-CLL.
Evaluation of the Prognostic Implications of Pro- and Anti-Angiogenic Cytokines in 311 Patients with Untreated Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia.
Geyer, Susan M. , Bone, N, Schwager, Susan M., Nowakowski, Grzegorz S. , Call, Tim G., Shanafelt, Tait D. , Lee, Yean Kee , Call, Timothy G., Zent, Clive S. , Kay, Neil E.

Blood | April 19, 2020 | Volume: 106 | Issue: 11 | Pages: 712-712

10.1182/blood.v106.11.712.712 Get It

Abstract Background: Angiogenesis has been found to be an important regulator in the disease progression of both solid tumors and hematologic malignancies. In solid tumors, the balance of pro and anti-angiogenic factors appears to be a critical factor in tumorigenesis, with disturbance in favor of angiogenesis promoting tumor growth and metastasis. This observation led to the concept of an “angiogenic switch” where pro-angiogenic influences outweigh anti-angiogenic factors. Patients with CLL have detectable levels of plasma and cellular pro and anti-angiogenic cytokines as well as abnormal neovascularization in the marrow and lymph nodes. Limited studies of pro-angiogenic cytokines have suggested that inter-patient variation in serum/plasma and cellular levels of these markers may have prognostic implications. We evaluated pro- and anti-angiogenic cytokines in a large sample of patients with CLL to evaluate the presence of angiogenic switching and its implications for disease progression. Methods: In a prospective, longitudinal study, we analyzed the serum/plasma, intracellular(determined by flow cytometry), and CLL B cell secreted (24 hour medium values) levels of pro-angiogenic cytokines (VEGF, bFGF) and an anti-angiogenic cytokine (Thrombospondin [TSP]) in 311 patients with previously untreated CLL. VEGF:TSP and bFGF:TSP ratios were calculated to evaluate for evidence of angiogenic switching (higher ratio suggests a pro-angiogenic phenotype). The relationship of angiogenic cytokines to Rai stage, IgVH gene mutation status, % CD38 protein expression, and time to treatment (TTT) from the date of sample were evaluated (median follow-up=11 months). Sequential samples were available on >90% of patients and were evaluated to assess if changes in levels of angiogenic cytokines occurred in patients requiring treatment. Results: Serum, cellular, and secreted levels of VEGF, bFGF, and TSP showed no correlation with Rai stage, IgVH gene mutation (continuous variable), or % expression of CD38 (continuous variable). However, among patients with Rai stage 0-II disease, individuals with lower TSP levels (<75 percentile, p=0.007) or higher bFGF:TSP ratios (continuous variable; p=0.003) had shorter TTT (Figure 1). Similar relationships for a shorter TTT were also observed for secreted TSP levels (p=0.007) and the cellular bFGF:TSP ratio (p=0.009). On analysis of sequential samples, no clear difference in serum, cellular, or secreted levels of VEGF, bFGF, TSP, VEGF:TSP, or bFGF:TSP occurred among those who required treatment. Conclusions: Angiogenic cytokines appear to have prognostic significance in patients with previously untreated early stage CLL. Importantly, we report the original observation that the ratio of bFGF (pro-angiogenic) to TSP (anti-angiogenic) correlates with time to treatment as a continuous variable. This result provides further evidence that angiogenic switching relates to clinical progression in CLL. Longer follow-up of this cohort is needed to fully define the prognostic implications of angiogenic cytokines in CLL and determine if integration of these markers with other prognostic parameters improves risk stratification for early stage patients. Survival According to Serum Thrombospondin Level Survival According to Serum Thrombospondin Level
The Physician-Patient Relationship Impacts Patient Quality of Life in Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia: Results of an International Survey of 1482 Patients.
Bowen, Deborah A., Venkat, Chaya, Reinalda, Megan S., Sloan, Jeff A. , Call, Timothy G. , Shanafelt, Tait D. , Slager, Susan L. , Zent, Clive S. , Kay, Neil E.

Blood | April 19, 2020 | Volume: 110 | Issue: 11 | Pages: 2060-2060

10.1182/blood.v110.11.2060.2060 Get It

Abstract Background: Chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) can have a profound effect on the quality of life (QOL) of patients living with the illness. To our knowledge, no studies to date have evaluated the influence of the doctor-patient relationship on patient’s emotional distress or QOL. Methods: We conducted an international, web-based survey of patients with CLL using standardized instruments to evaluate QOL. Additional questions on the survey explored how often patients thought about their disease and evaluated their satisfaction with specific aspects of their relationship with the physician caring for them. Patients were also asked to indicate what phrases their physicians had used to describe/characterize CLL. Results: Between June and October 2006, 1482 patients responded to the survey. The diagnosis of CLL was validated in a randomly selected subset of patients. Over half (55.9%; n=822) of patients reported they thought about their CLL diagnosis daily. Although the proportion of patients who thought about CLL daily decreased with time, two or more years after diagnosis over 50% of patients still thought about their disease every day. When asked to indicate their satisfaction with various aspects of the physician caring for their CLL, more than 90% (n=1340) of patients felt their doctor had a good understanding of how their disease was progressing (i.e., the stage, blood counts, lymph nodes) but only 69% (n=1024) felt their physician had a good understanding of how CLL affected their QOL (anxiety, worry, fatigue, etc.). Similarly, while 90% (n=1324) of patients felt comfortable talking to their doctor about treatment and management of CLL, only 77% (n=1134) felt comfortable talking to their doctor about how CLL affected QOL. Reported satisfaction with their physician in these areas strongly related to patients’ measured emotional and overall QOL on standardized instruments (all p<0.001). This effect on QOL remained (p<0.002) after adjustment for age, extent of co-morbid health conditions, measured fatigue, and treatment status in a regression analysis. Finally, patients were asked to indicate whether the physician caring for them had used specific phrases to describe CLL. Thirty-three percent of patients had been told “CLL is the ‘good’ leukemia,” 24% had been told “don’t worry about your CLL,” and 35% had been told “if you could pick what cancer to have, this is what you would choose.” Overall, 52% of patients had received one or more of these characterizations of CLL by their physician. The emotional and overall QOL were worse among patients who reported their physician had used these phrases to describe CLL (all p≤0.001). This effect on QOL remained after regression analysis (p<0.002). Patients whose physician had used one of these phrases to describe CLL were also less likely to feel their physician understood how CLL was effecting their QOL and to feel comfortable discussing the effects of CLL on their QOL with their physician (all p<0.001). Conclusions: Physicians play an important role helping patients adjust to the physical, intellectual, and emotional challenges of CLL. The effectiveness with which physicians accomplish these tasks appears to impact the QOL of patients with CLL. Additional studies exploring how physicians can best support patients with CLL are needed.
A Phase 1 Trial of Daily Oral Green Tea Extract in Asymptomatic, Rai Stage 0–II Patients with Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia.
Kaufmann, S., Call, Timothy G. , Wu, Wei , Bowen, Daniel A. , Secreto, Charla, Ghosh, Anjuli , Kabat, Brian, Yang, Chung S. , Jelinek, Diane F., Erlichman, Charles , Shanafelt, Tait D. , Zent, Clive S. , Bowen, D.A., Ghosh, A.K., Kay, Neil E.

Blood | April 18, 2020 | Volume: 110 | Issue: 11 | Pages: 2047-2047

10.1182/blood.v110.11.2047.2047 Get It

Abstract BACKGROUND: Green tea has long been touted as a health promoting substance. The active chemical compounds in green tea are called polyphenols or catechins. Epigallocatechin gallate(EGCG) is the major catechin in green tea. We previously reported the in vitro ability of EGCG to induce apoptotic cell death in chronic lymphocytic leukemia(CLL) B-cells in vitro (Blood 104:788). After publication of our findings, clinical activity in individuals using over the counter green tea extracts were reported (Leuk Res 30:707). Based on this information, we opened a phase I/II trial of green tea extracts for patients with asymptomatic, early stage CLL in fall of 2005. METHODS: The purpose of the phase I portion of this trial was to determine the optimal dose of EGCG in the Polyphenon E preparation for chronic daily administration and define tolerability in CLL patients. Previously untreated patients with asymptomatic, Rai stage 0–II CLL not currently meeting National Cancer Institute(NCI) Working Group(WG) Criteria for treatment were eligible for participation. Polyphenon E with a standardized dose of EGCG was obtained from NCI. The phase I portion of the trial was designed with 8 dose levels(range 400–2000 mg orally BID) using the standard 3 patient per dose level design. Patients remained on study up to 6 months. Grade 2 adverse events attributed to study treatment that did not respond to supportive care were considered dose limiting toxicity. The trial was designed to administer Polyphenon E in the fasting state. After accrual to dose levels 1 and 2, the U.S. FDA mandated all U.S. trials of Polyphenon E administer drug in the fed state. Accordingly, drug was administered in the fed state for dose levels 3–8. Trough plasma EGCG levels were measured 1 month after initiation of therapy. Response was classified using the NCI WG Criteria. RESULTS: As of August 2007, 33 patients have been accrued to dose levels 1–8. The maximum tolerated dose(MTD) has not been reached. Side effects have generally been mild. The most common toxicities were nausea(grade 1: 42%; grade 2: 3%), elevation in SGOT (42%; all grade 1), and abdominal pain (36%; all grade 1). To date, no patient has had a sustained 50% reduction in both absolute lymphocyte count (ALC) and lymphadenopathy that would meet the NCI WG criteria for partial response. A majority of patients have had a reduction in ALC(Table). Among the 10 patients who had palpable adenopathy at study enrollment, 7 patients experienced at least a 50% reduction in the sum of the products of all nodal areas at some point during treatment. Trough plasma EGCG levels after 1 month of treatment ranged from 2.93974 ng/mL(median 40.5 ng/mL). Plasma levels did not clearly relate to the degree of reduction in ALC suggesting sensitivity to Polyphenon E may relate more to characteristics of the leukemic clone than plasma EGCG levels. CONCLUSION: Daily oral EGCG in the Polyphenon E preparation was well tolerated by CLL patients in this phase I trial. The MTD has not been reached. As classified by the NCI WG criteria, no partial or complete remissions have been observed to date, however declines in ALC and lymphadenopathy have been observed in the majority of patients. The phase II portion of this trial will open at Mayo Clinic Fall 2007. Best reduction in ALC n % of patients At least 10% decline 25 76% At least 20% decline 14 42% At least 30% decline 8 24% At least 40% decline 4 12% At least 50% decline 2 6%
De Novo Deletion 17p13.1 Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia Shows Significant Clinical Heterogeneity: The MD Anderson/Mayo Clinic Experience.
Abruzzo, Lynne V. , Dyke, Daniel L. Van , Lynn, Alice, Keating, Michael J. , Tam, Constantine S. , Shanafelt, Tait D. , Wierda, William G. , Lerner, Susan A. , Kay, Neil E.

Blood | April 18, 2020 | Volume: 112 | Issue: 11 | Pages: 1056-1056

10.1182/blood.v112.11.1056.1056 Get It

Abstract Figure Figure In order to characterize the clinical course of patients (pts) with deletion 17p13.1 (17p-) CLL, we identified 100 consecutive treatment-naïve pts with 17p- from the MD Anderson Cancer Center (MDACC, n=61) and Mayo Clinic (n=39) clinical databases. The diagnosis of 17p- was established by FISH with a median time from initial diagnosis to FISH documenting 17p- of 9 months. Median age was 64 yrs (60 for MDACC pts & 70 for Mayo pts) and Rai stage was 0, 1–2 and 3–4 in 34%, 49% and 17% pts respectively. 17p- was the sole FISH abnormality in 29%. Unmutated IgVH and ZAP-70 positivity were present in 30/62 and 54/84 patients respectively. <<<TIME TO FIRST THERAPY>>> 69 asymptomatic pts were followed until they developed progressive disease requiring therapy as defined by the NCIWG 96 criteria. The 2 year actuarial risk of progression to initiation of therapy was 43% (46% for MDACC pts & 36% for Mayo pts). Only 2 of 10 pts with stable disease >2 years progressed on prolonged follow-up of up to 54 months. Two pts with baseline 17p- in 10% and 13% of nuclei lost their 17p- clone after 23 and 41 months. Independent predictors of shorter time to treatment were Rai stage > 0 (hazard ratio 7.2) and unmutated IgVH (HR 5.3). Pts with 0, 1 or 2 of these factors had a 2 year progression rate of 0%, 48% and >75% respectively (p<0.01). Other prognostic parameters such as ZAP-70 and CD38 did not have independent prognostic utility. <<<RESPONSE TO THERAPY>>> 41 pts from MDACC were assessable for response to first therapy. Overall (OR) and complete response (CR) rates were: rituximab without chemotherapy (n=6), OR 67% CR 17%; purine analogue + rituximab combinations (n=20), OR 75% CR 30%; purine analogue, rituximab + alemtuzumab combinations (n=13), OR 85% CR 54%. The pt who achieved CR after rituximab was negative for minimal residual disease assessed by flow cytometry and consensus primer IgH PCR, and has remained in remission at 29 months. At 2 years, 75% of complete responders remained relapse free. <<<SURVIVAL FROM 17P- DIAGNOSIS>>> Two year survival was 78%. Independent predictors of inferior survival were age 60+ (HR 3.4), B-symptoms (HR 3.7) and 17p- in nuclei 70+% (HR 6.0). Considering age 60+ and 17p- in nuclei 70+% in a prognostic model, 2 year survival was 100%, 82% and 55% for pts with 0, 1 and 2 risk factors respectively. Other prognostic parameters such as ZAP-70, IgVH mutation status and CD38 did not have independent prognostic utility. <<<CONCLUSIONS>>> Pts with de novo 17p- CLL exhibit marked clinical heterogeneity, with some pts experiencing an indolent course with prolonged survival. Survival and time to treatment among patients with 17p- can be predicted using clinical and biological characteristics.
Alemtuzumab and Rituximab for Initial Treatment of High Risk, Early Stage Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia (CLL).
Call, Timothy G. , Jelinek, Diane F., Tschumper, Renee C. , Secreto, Charla, Bowen, Deborah A., Geyer, Susan M. , Kabat, Brian, LaPlant, Betsy, Zent, Clive S. , Shanafelt, Tait D. , Wu, Wenting , Kay, Neil E.

Blood | April 18, 2020 | Volume: 110 | Issue: 11 | Pages: 2050-2050

10.1182/blood.v110.11.2050.2050 Get It

Abstract Background: CLL is still an incurable lymphoid malignancy. The current standard of care is to treat only patients with obvious clinical progression as defined by the National Cancer Institute Working Group in 1996 (NCI–WG 1996). High risk CLL can be identified at diagnosis by a variety of tests including fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), immunoglobulin heavy-chain variable region (IgVH) analysis, and expression of ZAP-70 or CD38. With this information we can identify patients with high risk, early stage disease who are candidates for novel low toxicity therapies that could alter the natural course of their disease. Our hypothesis was that combination monoclonal antibody (MoAb) therapy using alemtuzumab and rituximab would significantly reduce the high risk clone in early stage CLL. Methods: This phase II trial was conducted with IRB approval and accrued the planned 30 patients between January 2005 and July 2007 at Mayo Clinic Rochester. The study enrolled consenting patients with Rai stage 0–II CLL without NCI–WG 1996 criteria for treatment who had high risk CLL as defined as one or more of the following 17p13–, 11q22–, unmutated (UM) IgVH (< 2%) and expression of ZAP–70 (≥ 30%) and/or CD38 (≥20%). Treatment was one 30 day cycle (alemtuzumab 3 mg, 10 mg, 30 mg days 1–3 then 30 mg 3 × week × 4 weeks with all doses subcutaneously and rituximab at 375 mg/m2/week IV × 4 doses from day 8). Patients received 7 days of allopurinol and antimicrobial prophylaxis against PCP and herpes virus infections for 7 months. CMV testing by PCR was done weekly during treatment, then monthly × 6. Results: All 30 patients have completed therapy and 27 have been evaluated for response. The median age of these 27 patients was 62 yr (range 29–77) with 8 patients > 70 years. There was a male predominance (67%) with median time from diagnosis to treatment of 0.7 yr (range 0.1 – 6.1). Stage (Rai) at the start of therapy was 0 in 7 (26%), I in 19 (70%), and II in 1. High risk markers were 17p13– in 9 (33%), 11q22– in 7 (26%), UM IgV and expression of either ZAP–70 or CD38 in 11 (41%). All 27 patients completed therapy without interruption. Non hematological grade 3–4 toxicity occurred in 3 patients (2 drug reactions caused by SMX/TMP, 1 CMV reactivation responsive to IV therapy). Response evaluation at 2 months after completion of therapy using NCI–WG 1996 criteria showed an ORR of 93% with 12 (44%) CR, 8 (30%) nPR, and 5 (19%) PR. Two (7%) patients had disease progression. Median duration of follow up was 14.1 months (range 1.9 – 27.2). Median time to disease progression in the 25 responding patients was 14.4 months (95% CI 5.9 – 22.4). Seven (26%) patients have received subsequent treatment for CLL (median 5.2 months, range 2.4 – 20.1). A minimal residual disease assay using 3-color flow cytometry on peripheral blood was negative in 6 of the 7 patients with CR who had no evidence of residual CLL on immunohistochemical examination of the bone marrow. These 6 patients all remain in sustained CR (median follow up 15 months, range 2 – 27.2). Conclusion: Alemtuzumab and rituximab is an effective and tolerable therapy in patients with high risk early stage CLL. A randomized controlled trial is now required to test if this intervention is better than the standard observation approach. In addition, this combination MoAb regimen could be used as a platform to develop even more effective combination treatments for patients with CLL.
Treatment Free Survival of Patients with MBL and Early CLL: Follow-up of 405 Patients at Mayo Clinic.
Call, Timothy G. , Maddocks, Kami J. , Jelinek, Diane F., Boysen, Justin C. , Bowen, Deborah A., Schwager, Susan M., Jenkins, Gregory, Hanson, Curtis A. , Shanafelt, Tait D. , Kay, Neil E. , Rabe, Kari G. , Zent, Clive S. , Slager, Susan L.

Blood | April 18, 2020 | Volume: 112 | Issue: 11 | Pages: 2063-2063

10.1182/blood.v112.11.2063.2063 Get It

Abstract BACKGROUND: The diagnosis of monoclonal B-cell lymphocytosis (MBL) is used to characterize patients who have a circulating population of clonal B-cells, a total B-cell count of <5 x 109/L, and no other features of another B-cell lymphoproliferative disorder. In most patients the immunophenotype is similar to that of chronic lymphocytic leukemia with co-expression of CD19 and CD5. The natural history of CLL-phenotype MBL is unclear. We used the Mayo Clinic hematopathology database to identify patients with CLL-phenotype MBL and abstracted clinical information on natural history and prognostic parameters from clinical and research records. METHODS: Using hematopathology records, we identified a cohort of 1820 patients seen at Mayo Clinic between August 1998 and May 2006 who underwent investigation using peripheral blood flow cytometry and who were found to have a clonal B-cell population of CLL phenotype. After elimination of patients with advanced stage (Rai I-IV), previously treated CLL, and individuals with an established diagnosis of CLL/MBL >1 year prior to flow, 636 unique patients with isolated lymphocytosis were identified. Based on our prior analysis (Leukemia Research 32:1458) demonstrating that nearly all patients with an ALC >10x109/L have a B-cell count >5x109/L, we focused the remaining analysis on the 405/636 patients who had an ALC <10x109/L and the necessary raw data from flow cytometry analysis to determine the B-cell count. RESULTS: Among the 405 individuals with an ALC <10x109/L, 306 (76%) had a B-cell count <5x109/L at the time of flow and met the current criteria for the diagnosis of MBL (BJH 130:325). Median age at the time of MBL diagnosis was 70 years (range 34 – 93). A slight male preponderance was observed (59% male). B-cell counts ranged from 0.02 to 4.99x109/L and ALC ranged from 0.3–9.6 x109/L. CD38 status was available for 268 (88%) MBL patients of whom 20% were CD38 positive using the 30% threshold. Cytogenetic analysis by fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) was available in 130 (42%) MBL patients. Using the hierarchical classification system of Dohner and colleagues, 57 (44%) were 13q-, 23 (18%) were trisomy 12, 5 (4%) were 11q-, 4 (3%) were 17p-, and 39 (30%) had no defect detected. ZAP-70 status was available for 77 (25%) patients of whom 13% were ZAP-70+ positive. Patients underwent sequential monitoring with a median follow-up of 1.7 yrs (range 0–8.1 yrs). Time from diagnosis to treatment for patients meeting criteria for MBL (n=306) as compared to Rai stage 0 CLL patients with B-cell counts between 5.0 and 10.0 x109/L (n=99) was not significantly different and is shown in Figure 1 (p=0.87). For individuals with MBL, survival free of treatment was 98% (95%CI: 96–100%) at 1 year, 93% (95%CI: 89–98%) at 2 years, and 77% (95%CI: 67–89%) at 5 years. While gender (p=0.10), and B-cell count as a continuous variable (p=0.15) were not found to be associated with time to treatment (TTT) among MBL patients, age (p=0.02, HR=0.94, 95% CI: 0.89–0.99) and CD38 status (p<0.02, HR: 3.3, 95% CI: 1.2–9.2) did show a relationship with TTT. CONCLUSIONS: Although we observed a low rate of progression among individuals meeting criteria for MBL, TFS was similar to individuals meeting current criteria for Rai stage 0 CLL who had B-cell counts between 5.0 – 10.0 x109/L . Among individuals meeting criteria for MBL, younger patients and those who were CD38 positive had a shorter time to treatment. Additional studies are needed to determine what B-cell count or other characteristics should be used to distinguish between MBL and Rai stage 0 CLL. FIGURE: FIGURE:.