Kim, Simon P.

In this paper, we explore the relative value that different methods offer in answering some stereotypical comparative effectiveness research questions with the goal of informing development of a ‘translation table’ – a selection tool for choosing appropriate methods for specific comparative effectiveness research questions. This paper was written as a parallel effort to Greenfield and Kaplan (also in this volume) to support the endeavor described in the manuscript by Tunis et al. (also in this volume). Originally based on four cases, the current article has been shortened to two cases for the current discussion. These cases represent research priorities proposed to orient the work of the Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute, comparative clinical effectiveness and comparative health services.

What's known on the subject? and What does the study add? Postoperative complications for open radical nephrectomy ( ORN ), laparoscopic radical nephrectomy ( LRN ), and open partial nephrectomy ( OPN ) and its relationship with hospitalisation costs and mortality remain poorly described. The present population‐based study suggests modest differences in postoperative complications estimated at 27%, 23%, and 24% among patients with kidney cancer undergoing ORN , LRN , and OPN , respectively. Moreover, postoperative complications were associated with higher mortality, length of stay and total costs of hospitalisation. Objectives The association of complications after renal surgery for renal cell carcinoma ( RCC ) with in‐hospital mortality and costs remains to be defined. To describe the incidence of complications after open radical nephrectomy ( ORN ), laparoscopic RN ( LRN ), and open partial nephrectomy ( OPN ); and to evaluate its relationship with in‐hospital mortality and total costs. Patients and Methods We identified 49 983 individuals who underwent ORN (35 712), LRN (5327), or OPN (8944) for RCC at 2037 hospitals from the Nationwide Inpatient Sample 2001–2008. The outcomes assessed were in‐hospital mortality and total hospitalisation costs. Multivariable logistic regression and generalised estimating equations were used to test the associations between complications and in‐hospital mortality and total costs. Results With 26.0% of patients experiencing postoperative complications, there were modest differences in the proportion of patients with complications after ORN , LRN , and OPN at 27.0%, 22.6%, and 24.0%, respectively ( P < 0.001). After adjusting for patient and hospital variables, postoperative complications resulted in higher odds of in‐hospital death for ORN (odds ratio [ OR ] 7.20; P < 0.001), LRN ( OR 12.04; P < 0.001), and OPN ( OR 7.82; P < 0.001). Adjusted total costs also rose significantly with the presence of any postoperative complications compared with those without any complications for ORN ($21 242 vs $13 183; P < 0.001), LRN ($19 548 vs $12 555; P < 0.001), and OPN ($18 883 vs $12 098; P < 0.001). Conclusions With about a quarter of patients experiencing postoperative complications, adverse events for ORN , LRN , and OPN carry a significant risk of in‐hospital death and higher total costs. Efforts to reduce postoperative complications may correlate with substantial reductions in hospital mortality and total costs.

What's known on the subject? and What does the study add? There is great variability in the utilization of partial nephrectomy, but the causes of these variations are not well understood. The present study underscores the already observed phenomenon of surgical volume influencing surgical planning and outcomes, but it gets at why this might be so. We observe that high‐volume renal surgeons have different thresholds of ‘technical feasibility’. Objective To investigate why there continues to be wide variability in the application of partial nephrectomy ( PN ) for treating small renal masses despite guidelines in the US and E urope stating that a PN is a standard of care for a patient with a T 1 renal mass. Patients and Methods In June 2009, 764 surgeon‐members of the A merican U rologic A ssociation ( AUA ) participated in a survey evaluating the management of renal masses. Renal mass complexity was graded by nephrometry score ( NS ). Multivariable logistic regression models with generalized estimating equations were constructed to evaluate how tumour, surgeon and practice‐setting characteristics influence the use of PN . Results The survey response rate was 19%. Each urological surgeon responded to eight scenarios, providing 6112 evaluable cases. Tumour NS ranged from 4 to 10, and each unit increase in NS was associated with 59% increased likelihood of a surgeon offering RN on multivariable analysis (odds ratio [ OR ] = 1.59; 95% CI : 1.52–1.64). When holding patient and tumour characteristics constant, the following surgeon and practice‐setting characteristics significantly increased the odds of offering a PN: increasing renal case volume ( OR = 1.57; 95% CI : 1.27–1.95), academic practice ( OR = 1.80; 95% CI : 1.42–2.29), increasing PN % volume ( OR = 3.7; 95% CI : 2.46–5.55) and younger surgeon age (≤40 vs >50 years) ( OR = 1.64; 95% CI : 1.35–1.96). Conclusion The characteristics of a surgeon and the setting in which he or she practices influence the utilization of PN , the adherence to professional guidelines, and the threshold of tumour complexity at which a surgeon stops offering PN .